In October 1997, a family outing off the rugged North Mayo coast turned into a desperate fight for survival when a small boat was overwhelmed by the Atlantic. As darkness fell and conditions deteriorated, a team from the Garda Underwater Unit was dispatched to a remote sea cave, where an extraordinary rescue operation was unfolding.
Join hosts Helen Moorhouse and retired Garda Sergeant Dr John Reynolds as they uncover the remarkable events of that night, with a rare first-hand account from Ciarán Doyle, whose actions earned him the prestigious Gold Scott Medal for Valour.
A gripping story of courage, tragedy and survival, this episode explores the extraordinary risks taken by those who put their own lives on the line to save others — and the quiet modesty of a man who insists he was simply doing his job.
Presenters – Dr John Reynolds, Helen Moorhouse
Producer – Daryl Moorhouse
Sound Record and Mix – Sean Byrne
Recorded at Tinpot Productions Studios
Find out more or get in touch here
Póilíní, commonly misspelled as ‘polini’ or ‘paolini’ or even ‘poleini’, is the Irish word for ‘police’. The Póilíní Podcast covers stories from over 200 years of Irish policing history, from the Royal Irish Constabulary, to the Dublin Metropolitan Police, to An Garda Síochána.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Read the Transcript
00:00:03:01 – 00:00:19:16
Announcer
The Póilíní Podcast. Hosted by writer Helen Moorhouse and Dr. John Reynolds. Stories of duty and danger. Life on the law. Police and perpetrators.
00:00:19:18 – 00:00:45:11
Helen
Hello and welcome to this week’s Póilíní Podcast. I’m here with Dr. John Reynolds. Thanks for joining us. Our story today is another story about bravery, and what a story it is. And for a change, it won’t just be the two of us telling it. We’ll be hearing it from a very special perspective, that of someone who is at the centre of the story, who displayed the sort of bravery and dedication that just absolutely transcends the call of duty.
00:00:45:13 – 00:01:06:19
Helen
He’s a guy who risked his life for others. And almost 29 years to the day from the events of today’s story, he joined us for a chat and showed us what it really means to put your own life on the line for someone else. Our guest storyteller today is a man who epitomises courage and service, but who is extraordinarily modest, humble, and self-effacing.
00:01:06:20 – 00:01:26:05
Helen
So it’s really an enormous privilege to hear him tell his story in his own words, because while these events are on record, an account like this, a first-hand account, isn’t. And there are details here that probably few people would have heard before. And I think I speak for all the production team here at Póilíní when I say that we were speechless hearing the story from the horse’s mouth.
00:01:26:05 – 00:01:46:05
Helen
And I think that our listeners will be too. Ciarán Doyle is a literal hero, and he’s a very, very deserving winner of all sorts of medals for bravery, including a Gold Scott Medal for Valor. And it’s his story, the story of an extraordinary rescue at sea, that we’re going to hear about today. But you just know him as Doyler, or Ciarán, John.
00:01:46:06 – 00:02:02:00
John
That’s right, Helen. Yeah. I mean, everybody knows him as Doyler. I don’t think I’ve ever called him by his first name, probably. But we were on the staff at the college together. We were both training sergeants, and we kind of had similar personalities. We were both Dubs who loved telling yarns and swapping stories. And we were good friends.
00:02:02:00 – 00:02:16:23
John
Like, we’d have coffee a few days a week and we’d go for lunch. And, but there was one occasion where President [unclear] was visiting the college, and it was a very formal event, and we were all told to go out in the front square in our full uniform with tunics and the whole lot to meet the president.
00:02:16:23 – 00:02:33:18
John
And when I went down the square, I saw Doyler standing there, and I realised he had a medal on. Now, I didn’t know that, and I’d known him for years. And then when I walked up to talk to him, I realised it was a Gold Scott Medal, which left me kind of stunned. And then I saw beside the Scott Medal.
00:02:33:19 – 00:02:54:03
John
He also had a Heffernan Medal for marine gallantry and the RNLI medal, which, a Buckingham Palace visit, he had the job to receive on those. And I was absolutely stunned because I didn’t know he had any of those at all. And of course, being the college historian, I wanted to talk to him about it, and he kind of, like most medallists you meet, he’s kind of self-effacing, humble.
00:02:54:03 – 00:03:13:21
John
He didn’t really want to talk about it too much. And we did chat about it over the years, and I was delighted later on when he agreed that I could borrow the medals for the museum that I ran in the college at that stage, and they were on display there for several years, and they’re now actually on display in a temporary exhibition in the temporary museum called Order from Chaos.
00:03:13:21 – 00:03:31:11
John
And I’m privileged to have the loan of Ciarán’s medals because they don’t get out much and he doesn’t like to show them to people, for the same reasons. And so it’s a real privilege to be able to have him speak to us in this episode. To interview any Scott medallist is a rarity. And there are also very, very few gold medallists.
00:03:31:11 – 00:03:35:17
John
And any interview with any recipient of a Scott is exceptionally rare.
00:03:35:18 – 00:03:49:21
Helen
Sure. So we’re going to hear Ciarán talk a little bit about his own life and his own background in a minute. Up until now, we’ve been on dry land for all of our stories, but today takes us into the world of the Garda Underwater Unit. Tell us a bit about that, John.
00:03:50:02 – 00:04:12:21
John
Yeah, well, the Water Unit, I suppose, is a little bit of an Irish thing really, in that initially the Garda members that wanted to just do diving as recreation set up a sub-aqua club back in 1966. So these were just Gardaí with an interest in diving, as a social event really. So they were the subaqua club, but every so often the actual organisation would ask them to do jobs for them.
00:04:12:21 – 00:04:35:02
John
So in 1974, the Sub-Aqua Club kind of evolved into the unit when the job decided that they needed their own maritime unit, because there had been a famous incident, the MV Claudia, which was smuggling arms in for the IRA from Libya, and there were questions asked as to how come the Gardaí didn’t have any capacity to deal with marine-related issues.
00:04:35:02 – 00:04:44:02
John
So they decided to set up a unit of 12 members, most of whom had been in the club anyway, so their hobby kind of became their job really, you could say.
00:04:44:03 – 00:05:04:16
Helen
Wow, so it started from humble beginnings, and particularly essential on an island surrounded by water and full of water, lakes, rivers, etc. Ciarán is an incredibly deserving Scott medallist, and we previously told the story of Yvonne Burke, who was the first female Scott medallist in Ireland. If you haven’t listened to Yvonne’s story then check out our back catalogue of stories.
00:05:04:16 – 00:05:16:09
Helen
All the details are in the pod description. In that episode we touched very briefly on the Scott Medal. But before we hear Ciarán’s story, for a bit of historical context, tell us more about the history of this medal.
00:05:16:09 – 00:05:42:18
John
Walter Scott was a guy that came from a very humble background. His parents were Scottish immigrants who moved to Canada in the 1860s in search of a better life, then the family moved to the US, and Walter seems to have been a kind of a natural businessman, an entrepreneur, and he set up a stall outside Harvard College selling fruit when he was only about 10 or 11, and somebody spotted him and offered him a job with a company called Butler Brothers, one of the biggest retail chains in the US.
00:05:42:24 – 00:06:00:15
John
And Walter ended up moving to New York, working his way up the chain and becoming the manager of the entire business by the 1880s. So he came from nothing, and now he was an extremely wealthy man, and he had a very, what’s the word? Salubrious address of 495 Broadway in New York City. Now, he did an awful lot of charity work.
00:06:00:15 – 00:06:19:12
John
He seems to have been a really, really decent guy. He gave away most of his money, and he started to form scholarships for college for people who couldn’t go to college, particularly women, and also donating to hospitals. He was a big donor to hospitals, and because of the charity work he did, he came in contact with policemen and he developed an interest in policing and police work.
00:06:19:12 – 00:06:39:12
John
And he came up with this idea. He felt that the police officer didn’t really get the recognition he deserved for bravery. So he started to found medals. And it wasn’t just that he founded the Walter Scott Medal for bravery, he did it in New York, Massachusetts, Michigan and Argentina. And even today, the Boston Fire Department still has a Walter Scott Medal for Valor.
00:06:39:14 – 00:07:11:05
John
So he left a lasting contribution. So how did he end up being involved with the Guards? Well, he was made an honorary commissioner of the NYPD for his work in charity and in New York. And in May 1923, the new Garda Commissioner, Eoin O’Duffy, went to a conference in New York City of police chiefs. Now, we should say at this time the Civil War was raging in Ireland, and O’Duffy wanted to promote the fact that this was the newest police force in the world, the Civic Guard, as it was called, and it was patrolling unarmed and policing a country at civil war.
00:07:11:07 – 00:07:29:13
John
So obviously Walter was kind of gobsmacked with this. And Scott, perhaps true to his Scottish blood, was a huge admirer of Michael Collins. And then he met O’Duffy, who was one of Collins’s closest friends. So he took a particular interest in the Gardaí and he said, look, what your guys are doing, it’s incredible.
00:07:29:13 – 00:07:47:24
John
So I’m going to found a medal for you, like I’ve done in other countries and in other places in the US. So Scott had his own jeweller produce the first medal in solid gold, and he travelled to Ireland himself in ’24 to personally present the first Scott Medal for Valor to a Garda called James Mulroy. And it’s still an incredible honour.
00:07:47:24 – 00:08:10:03
John
It’s still awarded today. Fewer than 500 Scott Medals have been awarded since 1924, and initially there was only one category, gold, and there was only one a year. But they realised after a time that there were so many deserving cases, and they brought in new categories in the ’20s of silver and bronze. And the gold and silver recipients, like our story today, are only in double figures.
00:08:10:05 – 00:08:18:00
Helen
So in a nutshell, the Walter Scott Medal rewards serving officers for bravery. It’s a huge honour to win it, isn’t it?
00:08:18:04 – 00:08:38:15
John
It is, and it still is. Yeah. And it doesn’t, I suppose, get a lot of attention. I mean, there might be once a year there’s a ceremony and you might see it in the newspapers and people are interviewed. But the stories behind them, I’ve been at ceremonies in Templemore, and I’ve seen trainee Guards with their jaws just dropping when they hear what’s read out, what’s called the citation, what the medal is being awarded for, what instance.
00:08:38:18 – 00:08:55:18
John
And the students are looking at each other like, I can’t believe he did that or she did that, or am I expected to do that? Because it makes them think about what they’re joining when they joined the Guards. I think they don’t realise perhaps until they hear something like this the dangers that they might potentially face in their own service.
00:08:55:20 – 00:09:23:21
Helen
Our story today absolutely exemplifies the dangers and the vital work that the Underwater Unit does. So we’ll go from one extraordinary man in New York to another one in Mayo in 1997. We chatted with Ciarán in the studio recently, so throughout the episode he’ll tell us about his background and also the vital work of the Garda Underwater Unit, as well as then taking us through the events at Belderrig in County Mayo 29 years ago, and how they have informed his life and work since.
00:09:24:00 – 00:09:37:08
Helen
Plus, we’ll hear how he feels about being a gold medallist.
00:09:37:10 – 00:10:00:11
Ciarán
Well, I’m a Dublin lad. I went to school in Ballygall, St. Kevin’s, and grew up in Ballymun, and I spent the early part of my life on the north side of the city, very proud Dub, and got the opportunity to join An Garda Síochána a number of years ago and stuck with it for about 34 years. It was a surprise to me that I ended up with the Guards and a surprise to me that I.
00:10:00:13 – 00:10:17:02
Ciarán
I managed to stay the course without getting thrown out. Before I joined the Guards, I always had an interest in swimming. My father was chairman of the swimming club for a great number of years. Along with the pet dog, I was dumped into the Royal Canal, you know, and I think that’s where most of us got to learn to swim.
00:10:17:02 – 00:10:43:08
Ciarán
You know, when I joined the Guards, I was very, very happy to do the regular work, to walk the beat and meet the public and do all the jobs that regular Guards do. But behind it, I suppose there was always that inkling of, you know, I’d love the opportunity to join something like the Underwater Unit, you know, because it was very specialised, a small group of lads who kind of went around the country to very serious crimes.
00:10:43:08 – 00:11:07:02
Ciarán
And 6 or 7 years into my service, I got the opportunity to apply and was duly not picked, I suppose. Because I suppose it was still very early in my service, and then I had a second opportunity a number of years later, and I was lucky that time to be accepted and brought into the programme. Yeah, I was sent across to Scotland and trained up to be a commercial diver.
00:11:07:04 – 00:11:28:15
Ciarán
We worked with a number of different police services, the Scottish police and also the Newcastle upon Tyne dive team as well. So we trained alongside them, you know, to fully qualify. But as part of our training, we got to work alongside the lads who were in the unit before us and watch how skilled they were at doing the job that they did.
00:11:28:17 – 00:11:51:08
Ciarán
It was absolutely intriguing. These lads, you know, were exceptional. They were able to go into very adverse conditions, very often on the blind. They couldn’t see what was in front of them. They meticulously searched an area. And they were very robust and determined in what they did. I was hooked from the very first moment.
00:11:51:10 – 00:12:16:04
Ciarán
To really simplify it, the job of the Underwater Unit is to search areas that are unsearchable on land, if you like. So very often you’re looking for evidence, a lot of body recovery, munitions, firearms, drugs. And you think that that can be concealed underwater or in areas that are inaccessible, like it’s not uncommon for the Water Unit to be called into sewer systems and that type of stuff as well.
00:12:16:05 – 00:12:45:01
Ciarán
It’s not the most pleasant at times, but it’s an extremely rewarding job, you know, and very often the lads would be called in, they’d conduct searches, they’d recover very vital pieces of evidence, which would help conclude cases, so they could find more weapons, they could find the proceeds of crime, they could find munitions or explosives, which would, you know, connect criminals to the particular case that was being investigated, you know.
00:12:45:03 – 00:13:00:19
Ciarán
The navigational points are quite difficult, being able to guide somebody on the water. When I started in the water, you know, the communication systems weren’t as technical as they are today. It wasn’t possible to talk to a diver in the water. It absolutely is now, which is fantastic. So at the time when I started, we were using signals.
00:13:00:20 – 00:13:09:13
Ciarán
You know, pulls on a rope, little taps on the side.
00:13:09:15 – 00:13:33:20
Ciarán
To direct a team of divers who were underneath. You’re talking 40ft down and the person on the surface is guiding these people around the search area, making sure that every piece of that search area is being covered. If the person on the surface guiding us is watching and the waters are calm, you can see from the bubbles released from the tanks where we are on the surface of the water.
00:13:33:21 – 00:13:58:13
Ciarán
And that way he or she can also direct the diving team in the appropriate direction. You know, very often the lads and ladies in the unit are put into situations where the areas are very difficult to search. Deep canals or old lake systems that have a lot of debris thrown in them, could be searching through rubble and shopping trolleys and bits and pieces for a very small piece of evidence.
00:13:58:15 – 00:14:17:13
Ciarán
It requires a good deal of skill to stay in formation, stay in line and ensure that the immediate area that you’re searching is fully searched, you know, so we’re relying on each other the whole time, even for our own safety. And over time, you know, that becomes very, very paramount and strong. Each diver is relying on the person beside him.
00:14:17:15 – 00:14:41:23
Ciarán
Very often we would have been called to a scene where somebody has, you know, lost a life, either to suicide or accident. And obviously the families are very eager to recover their loved ones. And it’s a very sensitive thing. And as much as possible, we try to make that recovery as quick as we can. But we also have to bear in mind the safety aspects and the weather conditions, sea conditions.
00:14:41:24 – 00:14:50:02
Ciarán
You know, and as soon as we get a window, we would access it and try and do the job we were sent there to do. You know.
00:14:50:04 – 00:15:08:04
Helen
So the job they were sent there to do, there being Belderrig on the North Mayo coast, on Saturday, October 25th, 1997, the Saturday of the bank holiday weekend. When Ciarán woke up that morning, he didn’t know any more than any other day what was facing him, and neither did the Murphy family, who were from the area.
00:15:08:06 – 00:15:26:23
John
And that’s right, Helen. Yeah, the three family members were Tony Murphy and his wife, Carmel, and their daughter Emma, and they lived in Belderrig. And they also had a friend and neighbour, a man called Wilhelm Ernst von Bello. Now, he was a retired German businessman, aged 53, who had settled in the area, and they were friends of the family.
00:15:26:23 – 00:15:47:12
John
So he took them out on his new 16ft cork for a pleasure trip. So around 11 a.m. they set out by boat and the conditions were quite good when they left. But of course, being Ireland and the west coast, that didn’t really remain the case. They decided to have a look at the sea caves at Horse Island, and when they were over there, the weather turned very suddenly on them, and they got into difficulty.
00:15:47:12 – 00:16:18:16
John
And as they approached a cave at the foot of the cliffs, the cork was either overwhelmed or capsized. The family and Mr. von Bello actually ended up inside the cave. And then obviously the alarm was raised when they didn’t come back later on. And as normally happens with these events, local fishermen, you know, immediately came to the coast and started to search for people, and it was about 5:30 later on that day that the alarm was raised and a huge operation swung into action to try and find these people.
00:16:18:18 – 00:16:26:14
Helen
So let’s hear from Ciarán. What happened then?
00:16:26:16 – 00:16:41:00
Ciarán
I was actually in bed when the call came in. I suppose, sad to say, [unclear] a Garda car did come, and back then I suppose we didn’t all have mobile phones. It wasn’t uncommon for the Garda car to call to the house and, you know, for a Guard to get out and say, look, you’re required back at base.
00:16:41:01 – 00:17:01:14
Ciarán
You get to try and get the gear and get going. And as soon as we had the team together, the team would make their way to wherever we were required. Speed was always of the essence, evidence recovery or body recovery or whatever. But on this occasion, I suppose we arrived at Santry Station to be told, look, there’s a helicopter arriving at Dublin Airport and we can only carry a minimum amount of equipment.
00:17:01:14 – 00:17:21:18
Ciarán
Because of weight restrictions and fuel restrictions, there’s a number of people trapped in a cave in North Mayo, and the tide was rising and the family were at risk of drowning, and we needed to get there quick. So our immediate thought was that we’re going to have to go into this cave system, bring in extra bottles and dive this group of people out.
00:17:21:20 – 00:17:40:15
Ciarán
We made our way to Dublin Airport. We were met on the tarmac by the helicopter crew, who also briefed us on what they knew. So it was five Guards who were in this helicopter heading for the scene. We were trying to figure out, okay, what’s our plan of action? How are we going to do this? Because we weren’t allowed to take our normal equipment, we couldn’t bring our boats.
00:17:40:15 – 00:18:08:13
Ciarán
We couldn’t bring additional equipment. We had the absolute bare minimum. I mean, when we arrived at the scene, it was an incredible sight. And we arrived at a very small field beside the harbour in Belderrig, and there were hundreds of people at the scene. The field was lit up to allow the helicopter to land, and people immediately came forward to help us unload the equipment and get it onto a small little boat, which took us out to the scene.
00:18:08:15 – 00:18:18:11
Ciarán
The Coast and Cliff Rescue team were there and we travelled with two of their crew in their boat.
00:18:18:13 – 00:18:43:23
Ciarán
We had all our own search equipment. We had, you know, jackstay systems, we had rope systems, we had pulleys with winches. You know, we had lots and lots of stuff that we could have brought to a scene. But unfortunately, because of the time, because of the urgency, we actually had to just literally leave everything behind and take the bare minimum, you know, stripped down even, you know, the oxygen cylinders that we had, and took the minimum weight that was allowed for us to actually perform a dive.
00:18:44:04 – 00:19:12:03
Ciarán
So, you know, it really was the least amount of equipment in an emergency situation. There is what’s known as a scene commander, and the scene commander that night was a member, Superintendent Tony McNamara. Superintendent McNamara, as well as being the scene commander, was also a volunteer coxswain of the lifeboat. So he had a very good understanding of sea conditions and the types of hazard that were being faced that evening.
00:19:12:05 – 00:19:43:09
Ciarán
And he made a very courageous decision in sending this helicopter away from the scene back to Dublin to pick up the divers. He’d obviously seen the Garda divers in action before, knew our capabilities, and felt himself that, look, we’ll give these fellows a shot at this, and this is what’s required, you know. So it was a very courageous decision that he made, given the fact that he was also the scene commander, you know.
00:19:43:11 – 00:20:01:03
Ciarán
We travelled out in fairly rough conditions. They weren’t, you know, the sea conditions weren’t horrible at the time in the open water, but it was fairly rough. We arrived at the base of the sea caves, which are 600ft high, which are quite substantial.
00:20:01:05 – 00:20:26:01
Ciarán
And the swell was a lot bigger in there. There we saw the Ballyglass lifeboat, and that’s bobbing around like a cork, along with some fishing boats, local fishing boats, the local fishermen who had also gone to the scene to assist and who put themselves at risk that night, were taking a huge risk to help others. Well, what we were faced with was a sea cave that the water swell was entering the mouth of this cave, if you like.
00:20:26:02 – 00:20:52:05
Ciarán
We had no idea of the conditions inside and I think, to be fair, had we any idea, I don’t think we would have ventured in, but just because of the water conditions, we just weren’t able to gain access without actually entering the system, if you like. The larger boats were incapable of reaching the cave, but they were coming as close as they physically could to try keep an observation point at the cave, showing lights in to try assist, to see was there any signs of life in the cave?
00:20:52:07 – 00:21:16:07
Ciarán
Because at this stage we weren’t sure. They could have easily smashed into the rocks. And I mean, everybody was pushed to their own limits. But the decision was made by us that we would try and enter the cave system, have a better look into the cave system to see if there were any signs of life. So we did enter the water and made an effort to gain access to the cave with our gear on.
00:21:16:09 – 00:21:34:17
Ciarán
But as soon as we entered the start of the cave system, it was very, very obvious that that was not the way to go because the water was just unbearably bad. Very quickly we were all fighting for our own survival, if you like. We started off quite well. We were well coordinated, but the water decided what was doing inside in the cave.
00:21:34:23 – 00:21:47:03
Ciarán
So we ended up in a situation where it was very like being in a giant washing machine, if you like. The water was just absolutely going everywhere and so were we.
00:21:47:05 – 00:22:10:18
Ciarán
So we quickly retreated and made it back out and decided, okay, well, that’s not the way to go. And we had to kind of regroup and have another think about it. So what we decided we would do is we’d try to get in through the cave system using the small boat from the Coast Guard, and we’re trying to do a surface swim with ropes in to the family.
00:22:10:20 – 00:22:26:00
Ciarán
So a surface swim is not a dive. It’s not with the bottles on your back all the way. It’s literally a swim on the surface, bringing a rope system to the people who are at the back of the cave system and hopefully link up with them and get them out using the ropes back out to the water on the surface.
00:22:26:00 – 00:22:43:09
Ciarán
On the outside we are roped up to each other, so we were tethered to each other, so we were still using the older system, if you like. Again, it wasn’t possible to talk to each other or have any kind of communication other than the rope systems that we had. But very quickly we abandoned that attempt and made it back out.
00:22:43:11 – 00:23:00:11
Ciarán
Now, at this stage, we had got a sighting from one of the fishing trawlers to say that they had seen what they thought was a reflection from possibly a life jacket at the back of the cave system. So that really reinforced our idea that this is something we’re going to have to continue to do, because this was not going to be a recovery operation.
00:23:00:11 – 00:23:27:09
Ciarán
There was a possibility that there were still people alive there. So we had to do our best to try and bring these people out. I mean, that’s our function. And we’d also spoken to a diver from Galway, Josie Barrett, who had gone into the cave with another diver, Michael Heffernan. The two of them had attempted to enter the cave before we had arrived, and Josie experienced the same conditions that we did, and he managed to get himself out of the cave system, but unfortunately Michael didn’t.
00:23:27:10 – 00:23:52:20
Ciarán
He got pulled into the cave system, so that was the information that we had. So we decided a second time then, the second attempt, to do an above-water entry, if you like. So to get the boat in as close as we could, and when we reached the point of no return, if you like, we’d leave the boat and swim in with a rope towards the back of the cave and try make contact with the family that way.
00:23:52:22 – 00:24:03:02
Ciarán
Initially the plan was for just one of us to make the attempt. So look, it just happened to be me. It could have been any of the lads, to be fair.
00:24:03:04 – 00:24:21:21
Ciarán
Driving it, going into the cave, because of the height of the waves that were crashing behind us, the boat would have to be turned to face the wave to avoid it being turned over. So that happened a number of times that, you know, we’d have to turn into the wave, take the force of the wave, then turn the boat again, and then try to get in to the cave system.
00:24:21:21 – 00:24:29:03
Ciarán
We did that 3 or 4 times and got some access into the cave.
00:24:29:05 – 00:24:50:05
Ciarán
It was completely dark. The only light that we had was on the torches that we had with us as well, so we couldn’t see very far either. So it was quite a perilous task. Even then we made efforts, as I said, to get into the cave system, and 4 or 5 times we had turned back to face the oncoming waves.
00:24:50:07 – 00:25:05:08
Ciarán
And I left the boat and started to swim, but just as I did, a large wave came into the cave system, caught everybody by surprise.
00:25:05:10 – 00:25:31:11
Ciarán
And it flipped the boat up out of the water, the force of it. And then actually the boat went over my head. It was just completely, I’m in the water, if you can picture it, with the boat actually overtaking you. The boat was completely out of the water from the force of the wave, and I don’t know how it happened, by the grace of God, that I wasn’t struck by the boat, and the boat then actually hit the side of the cave system and was very badly damaged.
00:25:31:15 – 00:25:50:03
Ciarán
The bottom of the engine was ripped off the base of the boat, and all the other lads had to abandon the boat, if you like, and everybody was in the water at that stage. And before we knew it, you know, the entire rescue team that was there was now at the back of the cave, where we discovered the rest of the people who were there as well.
00:25:50:05 – 00:26:08:09
Helen
So this really is the type of scene that, unless you were there, it’s absolutely impossible to imagine. And Ciarán said himself that there was no point where he thought this might go horribly wrong, because that’s how he felt the whole way through. He felt that it could go badly wrong at any point. They’d been forced into the cave by Mother Nature.
00:26:08:09 – 00:26:11:19
Helen
John, what did they find in there?
00:26:11:21 – 00:26:30:17
John
Well, they find that the family are alive, but unfortunately, two of the people have been killed in the process of trying to rescue the family. Ciarán’s team discovered two fatalities. Now, Tony Murphy and his wife, Carmel, and their daughter had managed to find their way into a crevice or a tiny ledge at the very back of the cave, about a metre above the water level.
00:26:30:17 – 00:26:50:01
John
But the tide was rising, so it wasn’t a case of you could just sit there and wait for rescue. The waves were surging and the tide was rising and conditions were getting worse, and they were in grave danger of being swept away. At the inquest, Tony gave evidence and described that he moved his wife and daughter to as high ground as he could get as the waves were crashing into the cave.
00:26:50:03 – 00:27:14:18
John
Crashing in, he made a kind of makeshift barrier of rocks and boulders at the back to provide a bit of shelter. And unfortunately, he also found that the body of his friend and neighbour, Mr. von Bello, had washed against a rock, and he managed to secure the remains so that it would not be swept away. And unfortunately, Michael Heffernan had attempted to reach the trapped party with fellow Galway diver Josie Barrett and they got separated in the violence.
00:27:14:18 – 00:27:25:18
John
Well, Josie Barrett managed to get back out exhausted and unfortunately Mr. Heffernan, he had reached the family, but his body was subsequently discovered inside the cave as well.
00:27:25:20 – 00:27:51:05
Ciarán
We all ended up at the back of the cave and unfortunately that’s where we discovered the body of Michael Heffernan, the other diver who had gone into the cave system, and that was an awful sight to come across for ourselves as well. So we recovered Michael from the water, checked his vital signs. Unfortunately, he had passed. And then we met the survivors at the back of the cave, which was the Murphy family.
00:27:51:07 – 00:28:11:07
Ciarán
And so the young daughter, and we learned then that the chap that had brought them to the cave system, who had brought them sailing that day, a German national, William Ernst von Bello, he had also lost his life when they initially went past the cave. They were overtaken by waves and pushed into the cave system. And he unfortunately lost his life and drowned as well.
00:28:11:09 – 00:28:34:17
Ciarán
We were very lucky that we came across the family when we did and, fairness to Mr. Murphy, he did a fantastic job of protecting his family as best he could. He dragged, you know, a good number of rocks up against the family to protect them from the onslaught of waves. And also he covered the body of Mr. von Bello as well, to protect him in the best way that he could.
00:28:34:19 – 00:28:56:11
Ciarán
They were wearing lifejackets which were able to save their lives because it was the reflection from the life jackets that summoned the help, if you like, after the initial efforts. Otherwise it was just going to be a, you know, a recovery operation for us. You know, the danger that night was that we were going to lose the family because of hypothermia.
00:28:56:13 – 00:29:11:03
Ciarán
And it was, you know, a matter of urgency that we had to get these people out because hypothermia is a very real threat to life. And it’s something that we’re all aware of as well. So, you know, that was our first priority. Okay, let’s keep this family warm and let’s get them out as quickly as we can.
00:29:11:05 – 00:29:30:17
Ciarán
The words of encouragement were given straight away. Obviously, if you’re in a stricken position and help arrives, you’re very thankful for it. And, you know, there was hope for them, if you like. And the narrative did continue. I mean, like you said, we were able to say, look, help is on the way. Help is outside. We have lots of stuff set up, you know, let’s get ourselves out of here, you know?
00:29:30:17 – 00:29:48:04
Ciarán
So, yeah, the hope was passed on, if you like. We effectively were all caught and stuck at the rear of a very bad situation, if you like. I’m staring out into the abyss and the onslaught of waves is incredible. I remember one of my colleagues saying, nobody will believe the conditions that are in here this evening.
00:29:48:04 – 00:30:08:13
Ciarán
And he was absolutely correct there. Indescribable, you know, how bad the conditions were at the cave. You wouldn’t see it in a Hollywood movie, you know, a disaster movie. You know, it was really incredibly difficult and a fairly ominous situation to be in. We never had to face anything like this before, if you like. It was particularly bad.
00:30:08:15 – 00:30:29:00
Ciarán
My abiding memory was really of the sound of the waves hitting the cave system, if you like. It was like a train crash, a constant kind of train crash coming in, and the wall of water that was coming in was incredible. So you have a young family with a young 12-year-old girl. You have a father who is now in a situation where he knows his family’s lives are at risk.
00:30:29:04 – 00:30:47:17
Ciarán
He’s protecting his family as best he can. You know, he did a very, very incredible job on a very, you know, dark night in very precarious circumstances, you know, and I’m sure there are times he’s probably, you know, wishing that he never ventured out. But unfortunately, that’s what happened that particular day. And he ended up in circumstances he never envisaged.
00:30:47:19 – 00:31:06:22
Ciarán
But he did a great job, you know, as best he could. We decided that we would try and wait it out as best we could. We tried to warm up the family there and, you know, protect them from hypothermia. And at the same time, we were putting together a plan of our next strategy, which was to get us all out as opposed to just getting a small group out.
00:31:06:23 – 00:31:42:24
Ciarán
It was a case of, how do we get ourselves out of this situation? So what we came up with in the end was we put together all the rope systems that we had brought in. The lads from the Coast and Cliff Rescue were fantastic in that and, along with us, we quickly decided that we would try doing a surface swim in reverse, if you like, providing we got a break in the weather conditions or the sea conditions at the time, so we started to sort of chart and note when the larger waves were coming in and started to count the system and look for a window where, okay, the fourth or fifth
00:31:42:24 – 00:32:05:12
Ciarán
one here isn’t as bad. If we can get out to that particular point, you know, we may be able to get past that and move on to the next portion of it. So our plan then was to swim a rope out of the cave, out to the lifeboat or the fishing boats which were outside, and hopefully then, you know, be able to haul out the boat from the back of the cave system with everybody on board.
00:32:05:14 – 00:32:26:02
Ciarán
I suppose in the moment you’re just doing what’s trained into you. You know, you have to continue doing what you’re doing. And thankfully and luckily it paid off, we eventually did get them out of the cave and out towards the [unclear], which was being skippered by, you know, a fantastic [unclear] out there, who brought his fishing vessel very, very close to the cave’s edge and got out of the water.
00:32:26:05 – 00:32:44:19
Ciarán
Got the rope on board to his boat and the rescue continued. We weren’t the masters of our own destiny that night. There was no doubt we weren’t. And I’d be very quick to say that. I mean, I really think in my own mind that I was extremely lucky to get in and get out of that on that night, and we all were.
00:32:44:21 – 00:33:01:18
Ciarán
I was quite happy that we would be okay, that we were sufficiently well dressed, if you like, for the occasion, we were in what’s known as dry suits. We had equipment that would allow us to stay out of the worst of the conditions, and I was quite confident that eventually we could, you know, get ourselves out of the situation.
00:33:01:18 – 00:33:17:15
Ciarán
But it wasn’t the case for the Murphy family, this was the case of we have to move now or we’re in trouble. I know that I found myself saying a few prayers that I hadn’t said in a long time, on the way out of the cave.
00:33:17:17 – 00:33:42:06
Ciarán
The actual incident was one of the longest rescue missions in our history. It involved so many different agencies. I mean, we’re talking about an account this evening, but on that evening there were over 11, you know, agencies and volunteer groups. It was just incredible to see everybody come together at a time, I suppose, when that level of cooperation wasn’t normal.
00:33:42:08 – 00:34:06:06
Ciarán
And it was lovely to see that work recognised, you know, by the medal. But we went back to work. We went back to doing what we do best, you know, recovery, search operations, assisting people and investigating serious cases around the country.
00:34:06:08 – 00:34:31:12
Ciarán
Did it change me personally? Yeah, I suppose it did. I became quite appreciative of being around and, if you like, it was a nice reminder of my own mortality. And I do consider myself lucky even to come out and live the life and continue to do the work I did for as long as I did, and to continue with a very interesting and enjoyable life.
00:34:31:12 – 00:34:43:03
Ciarán
I’m glad to say I have a wonderful family and, you know, things are good.
00:34:43:05 – 00:35:01:24
Helen
And there we have it, a story for those of us who haven’t been serving Guards, unlike yourself, John. Obviously an event like this is just inconceivable. But what’s so striking, I think, is, again, the all-in-a-day’s-work perspective from Ciarán and any Gardaí who have engaged in events that most of us only see in the movies.
00:35:02:01 – 00:35:23:01
Helen
And of course, as Ciarán was so clear to say, he was part of a team and it’s only right that we mention the names of the other members of the Underwater Unit on that October night: Garda Seán O’Connell, Garda Joseph Finnegan, Garda Kieran Flynn and Garda Dave Mulhall, who was quoted in the Evening Herald afterwards as saying, we were just ordinary lads doing an unusual job. And, well, there’s unusual and there’s downright heroic.
00:35:23:01 – 00:35:36:20
Helen
And I think we can all agree that this is the latter. John, do you think that when Walter Scott was selling fruit on his stall before he moved to New York, he’d ever have envisioned this sort of honour being given in his name for these extraordinary acts of bravery?
00:35:36:23 – 00:35:52:10
John
I think, I mean, it’s amazing to think of Scott’s own journey as well, and his life story. But, I mean, Scott was very adamant when he wrote the wording for the award of the medal and he made it quite clear that you have to absolutely be in imminent danger of death, and you’re fully aware of that.
00:35:52:13 – 00:35:56:22
John
You have to be fully aware that you might get killed during this, but you’re going to do it anyway.
00:35:56:23 – 00:36:18:16
Helen
And that’s it from this week’s episode of the Póilíní Podcast, enormous thanks to Ciarán Doyle for taking the time to come and tell us his story. It was a real pleasure to chat with him and a privilege. Do you remember events from that bank holiday weekend? Were you there? Were you on a boat or on the shore? If you have any personal memories relating to this week’s episode, make sure to get in touch.
00:36:18:17 – 00:36:37:04
Helen
We’d love to hear your perspective and your recollections. Make sure to check out our free newsletter this week. You can see Ciarán’s suite of medals on there. Or if you’re in the area, you can check them out in real life at the Order from Chaos exhibition at the Tipperary Museum in Clonmel. Curated, of course, by none other than our own Dr. John Reynolds.
00:36:37:10 – 00:36:54:13
Helen
And if you’re enjoying the Póilíní Podcast, make sure to check out our back catalogue of stories. Give us a like, a follow and a share. Go to the podcast description. All the details are on there. Thank you very much for listening. We’ll be back next week with another story from our policeman’s notebook.
00:36:54:15 – 00:37:10:17
Announcer
The Póilíní Podcast, hosted by writer Helen Moorhouse and Dr. John Reynolds. Stories of duty and danger. Life on the law. Police and perpetrators.


